2009-05-31

Parabolic Telescopes


Last week as I was going through a whirlwind tour of conics to wrap up my Math Analysis class, I wanted to illustrate some real-life examples. Rather than just saying "these things are parabolas, these things are ellipses [etc]" I wanted to have the kids DO something with conics.

I'm not sure I succeeded, but I did come up with one activity that, with further work, could be a nice problem for future Advanced Algebra / Analysis classes.

I had a nice high quality picture of the Very Large Array in New Mexico, since my sister and I visited there on a cross-country drive. I wondered if it was possible to find an equation that would actually model the parabolic shape of the telescopes. So I popped the picture into Geogebra and constructed a parabola via the locus tool (which I just recently learned how to use).

The stated goal of the assignment is "find an equation for the telescope." I told them not to worry about the rotation. We could handle that later. (we didn't handle it, but perhaps next time, if this comes after matrices we could multiply by a rotation matrix... find the angle by inverse trig based on the slope of the dish)

But I think if I had used Geogebra with the kids more this year, they might have the capability to construct the locus themselves instead of me giving them focus / directrix. Basically, if they did what I did, I feel they'd get a good understanding of what a parabola is from a locus standpoint.

I didn't put this on the mathlet, but the diameter of one dish is 85 feet. Two ways to handle that: (1) rescale it so the geogebra numbers match it. (2) have the kids find the scaling factor (put points on the locus, measure the diameter using a segment). I like option 2, but that does require them to be well versed in Geogebra (goal: verse my kids in Geogebra next year!)

Well, I appreciate any comments / critique.

http://scottfarrar.googlepages.com/VLA.html

2009-03-21

f(t): Help Me With Some Algebra

f(t): Help Me With Some Algebra



Given a chord AB and the intercepted arc S, is it possible to find radius r algebraically? (problem stated at f(t)) The consensus there seems to be no, due to the transcendental nature of sin(x).

But I find it interesting that r could be constructed with a compass and straightedge. However, I feel like I'm cheating with Geogebra since I had to place C in order to draw arc S. So I really wasn't given S; I picked one based on C. Circular logic! (that's a little math joke ... ha ha ha.)

Update: http://www.mathforum.com/dr.math/faq/faq.circle.segment.html#1 Dr. Math has a nice page about solving circles given arbitrary parts. They reinforce the idea that this is a problem with numerical-only solution. Their solution involves Newton's Method, something I myself am not very well versed in these days!

2009-03-19

News Media



This XKCD comic reminded me of why I hate most of the News Media. The panel on the left is a pretty accurate rendition of a full screen graphic one of the 24 hour networks had up:

AIG
Bailout
: $170 billion
Bonuses: $165 million

At first glance, one might arrive at the conclusion that AIG was using almost its ENTIRE bailout for these bonuses. "How irresponsible! What an outrage! Despicable!" But upon closer inspection, one notices the difference between the numbers. What if we actually took the difference?

$170,000,000,000
- $165,000,000
= $169,835,000,000

There's $165 million is a drop in the hat. Its about 0.1% of the bailout money. It pales in comparison! It should not be compared. I'm not defending AIG. That's not the issue. The issue is the News Media is presenting information in a misleading format. I also assert the News Media is doing so purposely. They want the outrage, because outraged viewers will watch more. Everything is sensationalized and distorted.

The new propoganda isn't for political gain. The Media wants your viewership and your money. They will distort the facts for it.

Our financial crisis is a result of people misrepresenting information about loans rates, feasibility of real estate transactions, investment options and the market in general. People would bend the truth to gain more money. Now, the News Media is now misrepresenting information... to gain more money. They mimic the actions of the very organizations they codemn.

"Why do we have to take math?" students ask me. Look at the world. Those who understand the system will take advantage of those who do not. A simple concept like orders of magnitude (billions vs. millions) will be lost on many viewers who have been in the habit of non-mathematical thinking.

The next time stats or data is thrown in your face, by the Media or anybody else, pause and think: "what does it really mean?"



2008-08-24

Barackroll and Rickroll

full circle

2008-01-03

Wikipedia Crawl

I was channel surfing and stumbled upon The Late Late Show with Craig Ferguson. He was doing a Michael Caine impression and made some joke that I didn't quite get. Wikipedia to the rescue! or so I thought...

1:36 am
Michael_Caine
Scottish_English
Regional_accents_of_English_speakers
American_English

1:58 am: I split into two simultaneous tabs:

Branch 1:
Regional_vocabularies_of_American_English
--#The_West
Jefferson_State
State_of_Franklin
State_of_Lincoln
List_of_U.S._states_by_date_of_statehood
Historic_regions_of_the_United_States
--#Unrecognized_or_self-declared_entities
2:24 am

Branch 2:
American_English_regional_differences
California_English
--#Freeway_nomenclature
California_vowel_shift.png
Hyphy
2:24 am

There are some real gems in there. Never did find out what Ferguson was referencing though.

xkcd #214.